Recovered my old 2017 Parity account, but no luck transferring my ETH. Please help!

So I was able to access my old Parity account by downloading the Parity Signer app and using my recovery phrase. It shows me my address, but nothing about my holdings. I figured the fact that my account came up at all was a good sign though.

So I opened up Metamask to see if I could use the recovery key to recover it there and I got a recovery key error. This threw me for a loop since that same recovery key worked in Parity Signer.

Any ideas what else I can do to access the account?